Written by Q: What insurance companies write auto insurance policies in New Jersey
AIS Answer The Insurance division page for the State of New Jersey has all of the information you need regarding which insurers write auto insurance policies in New Jersey, including types, and contact information. We’ll print out the list of companies here for you as well.
AAA Mid-Atlantic Group
- AAA Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company of NJ
- Keystone Insurance Company
-  1-800-542-9544
- Direct AAA
-  Keystone
- www.aaamidatlantic.com
Allstate Group
- Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company
- Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company
-  1-866-222-4586
-  www.allstate.com
American International Group
- AIG Premier Insurance Company
- AIIC of DE
- AIIC of NJ
- 1-800-241-1188
- www.aigpcg.com
- www.aigdirect.com
Amica Property and Casualty Insurance Company    
- 1-888-592-6422
- www.amica.com
Atlantic Mutual Group
- Atlantic Mutual Insurance Company
- Centennial Insurance Company
- www.atlanticmutual.com
- 1-800-444-6161
Chubb Group
- Chubb Insurance Company of NJ
- Pacific Indemnity Company
- 1-800-252-4670
- www.chubb.com
Consumer First Insurance Company     
- 973-470-9843
Electric Insurance Company
- 1-800-342-5342
- www.electricinsurance.com
Esurance Group
- Esurance Insurance Company
- Esurance Insurance Company of New Jersey
- www.esurance.com
- 1-800-378-7262
Farm Family Casualty Insurance Company
- 1-800-843-3276
- New Jersey 518-431-5000
- www.farmfamily.com
Fireman’s Fund Indemnity Corporation¬¨‚Ć ¬¨‚Ƭ¨‚Ć
- 1-800-821-1818
- www.parkway.com
Founders Insurance Company    
- New Jersey 717-234-4941
- 1-800-388-4764
- www.pennnationalinsurance.com
Greater New York Group
- Greater New York Mutual Insurance Company
- Insurance Company of Greater New York
- 732-238-6300
- www.gny.com
Hanover Insurance Group
- Hanover Insurance Company
- Hanover New Jersey Insurance Company
- 1-800-257-5720
- www.hanover.com
Hartford Group
- Hartford Underwriters Insurance Company
- 1-800-771-8557
- 1-800-423-6789
- www.thehartford.com
High Point Group
- High Point Property and Casualty Insurance Company
- High Point Safety and Insurance Company
- High Point Preferred Insurance Company
- Teachers Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey
- 1-866-INSURANCE
- www.highpointins.com
- www.nj-teachers.com
IDS Property Casualty Insurance Company
- 1-800-535-2001
- www.ameriprise.com
IFA Insurance Company 
- 732-815-1201
- www.ifaauto.com
Liberty Mutual Group
- Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company
- Liberty Insurance Corporation
- Liberty Mutual Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company
- 1-888-889-9572
- www.libertymutual.com
Metropolitan Group
- Metropolitan Group P&C Insurance Company
- Metropolitan Direct P&C Insurance Company
- 1-800-438-6381
- www.metlife.com
National General Insurance Company GMAC
- 1-800-847-2886
New Jersey Manufacturers Group
- NJ Manufacturers Insurance Co.
- NJ Re-Insurance Company
- NJ Indemnity Insurance Company
-  www.njm.com
- New Jersey 609-883-1300
-  1-800-232-6600
New Jersey Skylands Group
- New Jersey Skylands Insurance Association
- New Jersey Skylands Insurance Company
-  www.njsi.com
-  1-866-279-7688
Palisades Group
- Palisades Safety & Insurance Association
- Palisades Insurance Company
- Twin Lights Insurance Company
-  www.palisades.com
- New Jersey 908-598-1112
- New Jersey Twin Lights 908-219-5050
Personal Service Insurance Company
-  www.personalserviceinsurance.com
- PHONE 1-800-954-2442
Proformance Insurance Company
- www.proinsureco.com
- New Jersey 732-665-1100
Progressive Group
- Progressive Freedom Insurance Company
- Progressive Garden State Insurance Company
- Drive New Jersey Insurance Company
- 1-800-PROGRESSIVE
- Progressive Freedom & Progressive Garden State
- Drive New Jersey
- www.progressive.com
Selective Group
- Selective Insurance Company of America
- Selective Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey
- 973-948-3000
- 1-800-777-9656
- www.selective.com
State Farm Group
- State Farm Guaranty Insurance Company
- State Farm Indemnity Company
- 1-800-624-1815
- www.statefarm.com
Travelers of New Jersey
- Travelers Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey
- 1-877-TRAVNJ1
- www.travelersnj.com
21st Century Insurance Company     
- 1-800-487-4500
- www.21st.com
Unitrin Direct Insurance Company  
- 1-800-253-7744
- www.unitrindirect.com
USAA Group
- USAA Casualty Insurance Company
- United Services Auto Association
- 1-800-531-8080
- www.usaa.com
Dang, that’s a lot of insurance companies in New Jersey. The rates in NJ are so expensive right now, you’d think with all of those companies writing policies in the state that car insurance would be a bit cheaper.
that’s a huge list of ins companies in NJ. I didn’t know so many wrote policies in that state.
New JErsey has a lot of insurance ocmpany.
AAA in NJ is great
New Jersey is getting better for car insurance thanks to the increased competition.